AIIM - The Global Community of Information Professionals

The IRS E-Mail Scandal, Or How the Dog Ate My Homework -- Information Governance

Jun 29, 2014 10:00:00 PM by John Mancini

I have been out of the country for about a week, so forgive my tardiness in commenting on the IRS e-mail story that has been percolating in the US press for the past week. 

Most of the press stories I’ve seen while on a belated 30th anniversary trip to Sorrento (we’re on the verge of our 34th anniversary, so I guess it’s about time) have centered around the poor performance of the British and the Italians and the Portuguese in the World Cup.  At the end of the personal trip, I attended an AIIM Executive Leadership Council meeting, but more on that in a minute.

iStock_000025329425Small[Note:  I do not intend this post as some sort of political statement. Really. There are lots of other folks out there who seem to love to tee up just about any story as an “Us vs. Them” story, regardless of the merits of the issue. I even saw one lunatic story during a brief foray into Facebook while on our trip equating the rise of soccer in the US with the decline of America. Sigh. I intend this as a post on information competency.]

So let me get this straight. 

Some excerpts from a June 23 New York Times article I am reading on-line “whilst” sitting in Heathrow (I thought I would use the British since I’m still here):

The commissioner of the Internal Revenue Service, John Koskinen, testified before the House Oversight Committee on Monday to answer questions about how two years’ worth of emails sent and received by Lois Lerner, the former official at the center of a growing I.R.S. scandal, could have been destroyed, and why the agency waited until just recently to tell Congress.
Q. How many emails are missing?
A. It is impossible to know for sure, because the agency says that the emails in question were destroyed when Ms. Lerner’s computer hard drive crashed in June 2011.
Q. Even if Ms. Lerner’s hard drive crashed, how could her emails have just disappeared? Were they backed up?
A. Apparently not, at least not permanently. Before it changed its storage policies last year, the I.R.S. backed up emails onto old-fashioned tape drives. Every six months, it reused those tapes, thus erasing the previous batch.
When many of these systems were installed, computer storage was much more expensive than it is now. So they were intended for “disaster recovery, not e-discovery” for legal purposes, said Jonathan Feldman, the chief information officer for the City of Asheville, N.C., who has consulted for large companies and written extensively about data management practices. “I.T. people weren’t concerned with document retention.”

And then another piece from CNN on June 24:

David Ferriero, who heads the National Archives and Records Administration, told a House panel that the IRS "did not follow the law" when it failed to tell his agency about the loss of emails belonging to former IRS official Lois Lerner.

And then another story PoliticoPro on June 26 noting “EPA joins IRS lost emails club."

You just can’t make this stuff up.

To make this doubly ironic, the aforementioned Executive Leadership Council meeting I attended at the end of our anniversary trip was on Information Governance

In a digital economy, how you manage your digital assets is just as important as how you manage your physical assets or your financial assets or your people assets.  And certainly the history of either political party is loaded with stories about the abuse of electronic information. 

Regardless of political persuasion, though, saying that multiple simultaneous personal hard drive crashes caused the loss of the emails in question stretches the imagination. Saying that you can’t produce emails because your hard drive crashed is the digital equivalent of “the dog ate my homework.” In this era, organizations should simply know better than to expose themselves to this kind of information management risk -- the net result is an endless cycle of skeptical question that is endlessly distracting and destructive.

So the offer I will make right now is admittedly self-serving.  If you are in the press covering this story, or an end user trying to figure out how to do this information governance thing responsibly, here are some links to get information on this pesky issue of Information Governance and the responsible management of email. 

Whether through AIIM or someone else, get on with it. Don’t wait until you are on the front page of the New York Times.


A few more resources that might be of interest...

View FREE Video Here!

Like what you see? Subscribe to get updates delivered straight to your inbox.

Back to Blog

About AIIM

AIIM provides market research, expert advice, and skills development to an empowered community of leaders committed to information-driven innovation.

Click to download - 2017 State of Information Management

Subscribe to Email Updates